4) American Gangster

3) Gone Baby Gone

2) Spider-Man 3

1) Knocked Up

For the first time, we relied completely on your votes to compile our list of the Top Five Overrated Films of 2007. Two of these don't surprise me (Gone Baby Gone and Spidey). But I didn't realize people were aware of how exceedingly good Enchanted was viewed critically and by audiences. I personally didn't love it, but many did.

I also thought American Gangster was overrated, but the reaction I got at the time was that I was an idiot. Finally, Knocked Up, which is overrated, got the most votes of any film in our little contest. So, you're the big winner, Judd Apatow.