website tracking
Search The Big Picture
« Movie Review - 'The Great Buck Howard' | Main | Movie Review - 'Sunshine Cleaning' »
Friday
20Mar2009

Movie Review - 'Crossing Over'

Crossing Over

Starring Harrison Ford, Ray Liotta, and Ashley Judd
Directed by Wayne Kramer
Rated R



crossingoverposter.jpg Immigration is a thorny issue with no quick, easy, or perfect solution. How do you juggle talk of a wall along our border with the promise of America? How do you keep everyone out when the Statue of Liberty asks for your tired, poor, and huddled masses? How do you stop immigration in a nation of immigrants?

Conversely, an approach that takes all comers has at least as many problems as the one that wants restrictions. Jobs, crime, medical care and costs, insurance, and overpopulation are some of the concerns that America faces after living with a fairly lax immigration policy.

Crossing Over tries to tackle the problem in two hours, which would be difficult to pull off if writer-director Wayne Kramer had kept his new film limited to one or two stories of illegal immigrants trying to find a way to stay in the country.

Unfortunately, there are seven distinct but intertwined storylines, which could work if this were The Love Boat and the plot points were easy to establish and required little involvement with the details. But because Kramer does have seven stories, what sets them apart are their details, and there's just not enough time to do them justice.

Admirably, Kramer does not limit Crossing Over to immigrants heading north from Central America. There's an Australian actress (Alice Eve), an Iranian family and a Korean family near the end of their journeys to naturalization, a British musician (Jim Sturgess) trying to con his way into permanent residency, a Mexican laborer (Alice Braga) and her displaced son, an orphaned African refugee caught in the system, and an outspoken Muslim teenager, whose actions in school threaten to have her entire family deported.

There needs to be some connective tissue between those stories, of course. Kramer has given us an immigration lawyer (Ashley Judd) and her husband (Ray Liotta), who also has some pull in that department. But we see most of this film through the eyes of INS officer Max Brogan (Harrison Ford).

Considering the individual stories, it is sometimes hard to feel sympathy for the immigrants. Most of them lie, some commit actual felonies, and one pulls her entire family into one big mistake. It's unclear whether Kramer intends to make us have that reaction. More than likely, he didn't want to introduce a dozen characters and have the audience side only with Harrison Ford and Ashley Judd.

The idea behind Crossing Over is a good one, and weighing all the key performances, it's a well-acted film, even if the storylines tend to lean a little more extreme than they need to. But it would work better as a gritty cable show, where each of these stories and many others would be allowed to live and breathe with fewer time restrictions. There are important lessons to learn here, but it's difficult to absorb everything Wayne Kramer is trying to show us.


Watch the Crossing Over trailer

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>